Legal Help Backed By Decades Of Experience We'll Come to You

Photo of Victor C. Mitchener and Joseph H. Downer
"Photo of Victor C. Mitchener and Joseph H. Downer"

Victor C. Mitchener, Attorney

Joseph H. Downer, Attorney

How does North Carolina determine fault in a car accident?

On Behalf of | Sep 9, 2025 | Motor Vehicle Accidents

Determining fault in a car accident is an essential part of the claims process. In North Carolina, understanding how fault is assessed can help drivers protect their rights and handle insurance claims. 

Contributory negligence rule

North Carolina follows a contributory negligence rule. This means that if a person is even 1% at fault in the accident, they may lose eligibility to receive compensation for injuries. This strict rule can make it difficult for some individuals to claim damages if they share any responsibility for the accident. However, insurance companies and courts still evaluate the facts to determine who is responsible for the crash.

Gathering evidence

In car accident cases, gathering evidence plays a significant role in determining fault. State law requires drivers involved in accidents to report the incident to law enforcement if injuries or significant property damage occur. Police reports often clarify the details of the accident. Additionally, other forms of evidence, such as photographs of the scene, witness statements, and traffic camera footage, can provide valuable insights into how the accident occurred and who caused it.

Insurance company investigation

After an accident, insurance companies investigate to determine fault. They review the evidence, police reports, and any statements made by the involved parties. In some cases, the insurance company may assign partial fault to one or more parties based on their findings. The assessment of fault by the insurance company influences the claims process and whether compensation is granted.

Accurately determining fault is important because of the state’s contributory negligence law. Drivers involved in accidents should understand how fault is assessed and ensure that they gather all necessary evidence to protect their rights.