Legal Help Backed By Decades Of Experience We'll Come to You

Photo of Victor C. Mitchener and Joseph H. Downer
"Photo of Victor C. Mitchener and Joseph H. Downer"

Victor C. Mitchener, Attorney

Joseph H. Downer, Attorney

Can dashcam footage be used as evidence in accident cases?

On Behalf of | Oct 7, 2024 | Motor Vehicle Accidents

Understanding the role of dashcam footage in accident cases is important. While this footage can serve as valuable evidence, specific factors determine its admissibility in court. Knowing these legal standards can help clarify whether the footage will support or hinder a case.

Dashcam footage

Courts will admit dashcam footage as evidence if it meets legal standards outlined under the North Carolina Rule of Evidence 401, which requires the evidence to be relevant. The footage must be properly authenticated under Rule 901, meaning the party submitting it must prove that the footage accurately depicts the events in question without alterations. Any signs of tampering or editing can lead to the court rejecting the footage.

Clear, unedited, and reliable footage is critical for its admissibility. If the footage meets these criteria, it can serve as strong evidence in accident cases.

Proving fault

Dashcam footage can play a significant role in proving fault by capturing key moments of an accident. In North Carolina, contributory negligence laws bar a person from recovering damages if they are even 1% at fault. This makes dashcam footage critical, as it provides visual evidence that can clarify responsibility. By offering a clear account of the accident, the footage can help assign liability fairly, ensuring the correct party is held accountable under the strict contributory negligence rule.

Potential challenges

Despite its advantages, dashcam footage can face obstacles in court. Under North Carolina Rule of Evidence 403, courts may exclude evidence if something compromises the quality. They may reject it if the evidence causes more harm than good by creating bias or confusion.

Accident cases

Dashcam footage can offer crucial insights in car accident cases, but its value depends on meeting strict legal requirements. Proper handling of this evidence can make a significant difference in determining the outcome.